What are the benefits of a granny flat interest?
Declining housing affordability and difficulty getting into the owner-occupied real estate market may cause children to rely on their parents for assistance. However, the parents’ wealth may be tied up in their own homes, making it difficult to help as well as maintain their own independence. Older parents may also be looking for a care solution that does not involve moving to an external care situation.
(Granny flat interests do not need to be established between family members, but for convenience we are using families in our writings because this is the most common form of granny flat arrangement.)
Granny flat arrangements offer mutual benefits for families. For children, the advantages include:
- Early housing access: Get earlier access to owner-occupied housing market.
- Home upgrades: Improving or extending the family home.
- Family support: Receiving help with household chores and childcare from parents.
For older parents, granny flats provide several benefits:
- Family connection: Maintaining regular interaction with children and grandchildren helps reduce loneliness.
- Independence: Enabling them to stay in their own homes longer, avoiding external care facilities.
- Practical support: Receiving assistance with daily tasks and care when frailty becomes an issue.
- Financial flexibility: Accessing home equity while securing a stable living situation, offering an alternative to retirement villages or other care options.
- Estate planning: Keeping assets within the family and potentially avoiding gifting and deprivation rules by transferring assets through granny flat provisions.
- Security: Ensuring accommodation for life.
Risks of granny flats?
Granny flat interests are normally established when the relationship between both parties is good. At this point, the parties see mutual benefits in the arrangement and are often blind to the risks or ignore the risks with an attitude of, “it could never happen to me or in my family”.
There are many cases of elder abuse in the courts which arise from granny flat arrangements, and this can leave older parents vulnerable. But problems don’t only occur because of the ill-will of one party. Unforeseen circumstances can also arise. These may include:
- Family dynamics: Problems may occur if relationships sour or if elder abuse arises, leaving older parents vulnerable.
- Unforeseen events: Situations such as the child’s death, severe illness, financial troubles, divorce, or unexpected work relocation can disrupt the arrangement.
- Parental issues: Parents might need to move to aged care, face marital or financial difficulties, or feel constrained by the arrangement.
The practical reality of living together might differ from expectations, leading to dissatisfaction or strained relations. Addressing issues as they arise can be challenging, especially for older parents who may face difficulties enforcing their accommodation rights. Parents might have given up their legal title to property for an informal arrangement.
Legal advice and a written legal agreement might help to avoid some issues, or at least provide remedies when things go wrong.
Formalising granny flat arrangements
A written agreement formalises the terms and conditions of a granny flat arrangement and designs an exit strategy in a formal document. Putting the agreement in writing forces the parties to think long term, consider what will happen if the agreement is no longer workable or if an unplanned event occurs.
Setting in place a formal agreement establishes each party’s rights and responsibilities and can help to protect against elder abuse. There is no prescribed format (and from a Centrelink/DVA perspective the agreement doesn’t have to be in writing to exist). But agreements might contain:
- Purpose and background: Clarify the intent and details of the arrangement.
- Occupancy rights: Specify what the parents are entitled to occupy.
- Financial aspects: Detail the payment for occupancy and responsibility for expenses.
- Maintenance responsibilities: Specify who handles repairs and maintenance on the property, from small issues to major structural concerns.
- Household duties: Outline any tasks or childcare duties the parent will perform
- Care provisions: Describe the care that will be provided as the parent ages.
- Dispute resolution: Include methods for resolving conflicts and registering a caveat if needed.
- Termination terms: Define the conditions under which the agreement can end, either voluntarily or involuntarily. Detail how it will conclude, including any financial settlements and the method for calculating or valuing these payments.
Minimising risks?
To minimise risks associated with granny flat arrangements, consider the following:
- Avoid rushed decisions: Take time to consider the arrangement fully.
- Seek professional advice: Consult with both legal and financial experts to understand the implications, now and in the future.
- Document everything: A well-drafted agreement provides a clear framework and helps protect all parties.
Granny flat arrangements can be beneficial, but they require careful planning and legal documentation to ensure they meet the needs of both parties and prevent potential conflicts.
For more guidance or to set up an appointment, call us at 02 4325 0884 or inquire about aged care options during your next review meeting.
Sophie Doyle (AR#000470612) is a Retirement and Aged Care Specialist at Morgans Financial Limited Gosford (Morgans AFSL 235410 / ABN49 010 669 726); with a passion for assisting families make informed financial decisions, as they navigate their way through retirement and aged care.
.jpg)
