Direct investment or managed investment? Neither is automatically better, and plenty of investors use both. The real question is how much control, convenience and tax management you want.

Key takeaways

  • A fully franked 5% dividend yield grosses up to roughly 7.1% before personal tax, using a 30% company tax rate.
  • Selling listed shares settles in 2 business days, while managed fund redemptions are generally slower.
  • Retail funds can charge around 1% to 1.5% a year more than wholesale funds.
  • Many investors combine 2 approaches to balance control, diversification and professional management.

What is direct investment?

Direct investment means buying listed securities, such as shares, yourself or through your adviser. You choose what to hold and when to buy or sell. The benefits include:

  • Control over timing, so you decide when to realise gains or losses.
  • Franked dividends, which carry tax credits.
  • Liquidity, because the ASX lets you buy, sell or rebalance quickly.
  • Clarity, because you can see exactly what you own.

How do you buy and sell? You place orders through your adviser or broker, and trades happen on the ASX at the prevailing price.

The trade-offs. You carry concentration risk if you hold too few companies, you pay brokerage on each trade, and you need time to research and monitor.

What are the benefits of managed funds?

A managed fund pools your money with other investors, and specialist managers invest it on your behalf. Most are unit trusts, so you buy units whose price rises and falls with the fund's investments. The benefits include:

  • Professional research and monitoring.
  • Administration handled for you, including annual tax statements.
  • Easier diversification across asset classes.
  • Access to markets that are hard to reach alone, such as international and emerging markets.
  • Regular investing, with distributions that can be reinvested to compound.

How are units priced? The fund values its assets at prevailing market prices, and the unit price reflects that value. If you redeem when prices are low, you may need to sell more units to raise a set dollar amount.

The trade-offs. Redemptions are slower than selling listed shares, and you can't control when the fund realises gains.

Why does diversification matter? Spreading money across asset classes means a fall in one area may be offset by gains in another. It can moderate volatility, but it doesn't remove losses.

How do tax and fees compare?

  • Direct: you can manage capital gains and losses to suit your own tax position, and brokerage is the main cost.
  • Managed funds: managers often turn over holdings, so distributions can include realised gains you can't time. Fees may include entry, exit, management and performance fees.
  • Index vs active: index funds usually charge less than active funds.
  • Wholesale vs retail: retail funds can charge around 1% to 1.5% a year more than wholesale funds.

Wholesale access generally needs a larger starting investment, from around $20,000 up to $500,000, or a platform that adds its own administration fee. Fund managers must show returns net of fees, which makes like-for-like comparisons easier.

Why compare yields carefully? A common mistake is comparing a bank rate with a dividend yield. Interest is fully taxable, while franking credits are built into dividends, so the two need grossing up before you compare them.

Which investors suit each approach?

Direct investment may suit people who:

  • Want control over what they hold and when they sell.
  • Have enough invested to spread across several companies.
  • Are comfortable monitoring their holdings.

Managed funds may suit people who:

  • Prefer convenience and professional management.
  • Want to invest regularly in smaller amounts.
  • Want exposure to markets that are hard to reach directly.

Both carry risk. Managed funds spread money across many holdings, but unit prices can still fall and fees reduce returns. Direct holdings can be more concentrated.

What should you check before choosing a fund?

  • The product disclosure statement and target market determination.
  • All fees, including entry, exit, management and performance fees.
  • The manager's approach and how it fits your goals.
  • How often the fund pays distributions.
  • Past returns, which don't predict future results.

How do you choose between direct investment and managed funds?

Start with four questions:

  • How hands-on do you want to be?
  • How large is your portfolio?
  • What's your tax position?
  • Do you want international exposure?

Many investors blend both. Exchange traded funds also sit between the two, and our ETF service explains how they work. Our buy and sell shares service covers the direct route, and portfolio construction looks at how the pieces fit together.

Managed funds often suit regular savings plans, so it's worth reading about dollar-cost averaging vs lump sum investing. For the wider picture, our guide to investing compares the main options.

There's no single right answer, only the one that suits your goals. To design an approach around yours, find a Morgans adviser.

      
Contact us
      

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

Do managed funds pay dividends?

Not exactly. Managed funds pay distributions, which can include dividend income, interest, franking credits and realised capital gains, so check a fund's distribution history before you invest.

What's the main difference between direct investment and managed investment?

Direct investing gives you control over timing, tax and what you hold. Managed funds give you professional management and diversification in one holding.

Can I combine direct investing and managed funds?

Yes, and many investors do. A mix can balance control, diversification and access to specialist managers, so ask your adviser how to split it.

How do fees differ between managed funds and direct investing?

Managed funds can charge entry, exit, management and performance fees, while direct investing usually has brokerage on each trade. Index and wholesale funds are often cheaper, so compare fees net of returns.

Are there tax benefits to direct investing?

Yes, including franking credits and control over when you realise capital gains. Your own tax position matters, so confirm the detail with your accountant.

Disclaimer: The information contained in this report is provided to you by Morgans Financial Limited (AFSL 235410) as general advice only, and is made without consideration of an individual's relevant personal circumstances. Morgans Financial Limited ABN 49 010 669 726, its related bodies corporate, directors and officers, employees, authorised representatives and agents (“Morgans”) do not accept any liability for any loss or damage arising from or in connection with any action taken or not taken on the basis of information contained in this report, or for any errors or omissions contained within. It is recommended that any persons who wish to act upon this report consult with their Morgans investment adviser before doing so.

News & Insights

Looking for a child trust fund in Australia? There isn't a government scheme, so most families invest through an account an adult holds on the child's behalf. Get the structure wrong and the tax can be steep, so here's how it works.
Read full article
Direct investment or managed investment? Neither is automatically better, and plenty of investors use both. The real question is how much control, convenience and tax management you want.
Read full article
Your Wealth covers EOFY super tips, CGT reform impacts, the 2026 Federal Budget, franking credit changes, and Division 296, essential reading for investors.
Read full article